There’s nothing more frustrating than working with machinery or building something that requires the continued tightness of fasteners. That bolt you just tightened last week is loose again. That connection you swore was snug just a few days ago is rattling today. Not that the fastener failed, but rather, the forces upon it worked their magic to get it inoperable.
Table of Contents
How and Why it Becomes Loose In the First Place
The problem is basic. When a bolt/screw is tightened, tension ensues; the fastener is being stretched slightly but its tension is what’s holding everything together through clamping force. Vibration, thermal expansion, and movement counteract that. Each vibration, temperature change, and minuscule flex reduces clamping force until there’s none holding it together anymore.
We think of looseness as backing out threads. Yet, that’s not always the case. More often than not, it’s merely the loss of clamping force. The fastener may appear to be tight but the power doing the work has dissipated. By the time we see something moving or hear a rattle, it’s been loose for some time.
What’s the Worst Environment for Loosening
Heavy machinery takes the biggest hit. Anything that has an engine, factory apparatus or construction vehicle constant vibrations put every connection to the test. It’s not that larger forces happen in each moment, but they’re constant. Thousands of movements a minute seeking to undo what a person just did.
Temperature cycling wreaks its own havoc. Heating and cooling cycles expand materials differently based on differential expansion rates. The aluminum materials housing a steel connection experience different movement than the two pieces experiencing temperature changes simultaneously. This too is movement, and movement causes clamping force to change. After enough cycles, it’s compromised.
Impacts and shock loads are horrible surprises. A sudden jolt can push against enough friction in place to loosen a fastener. All it takes is a quarter turn for something to start moving and once it does, there’s no stopping it. Each time it’s impacted, it gets worse.
What’s Traditionally Done With Fasteners to Compensate for Loosening
Lock washers have been in existence forever and while they help many do not understand how or why. A split lock washer cannot truly “bite” into anything enough for rotational power to cease an effort. Instead, a split lock washer gives enough spring-like tension compensation for settling and minor loosening efforts. Low vibrational applications work best with this technique; however, high energy forces render it useless.
Thread locking compounds are great alternatives, however. These chemical adhesives fill gaps between threads when new and act like hard glue when they cure. They cure to different strengths some can be undone with hand tools others require heat but the differential approach is good. However, they need clean and prepped workspaces and threads to be effective for reuse if not, one must take time to clean and reapply.
Nylon insert lock nuts (nylock nuts) come equipped with collars that create friction against threads however, they’re effective initially but then the plastic bends so they’re one-time-use fasteners despite how cheap they seem to be able to reuse. So many reuse them without realizing why it doesn’t hold tight a second time.
Where Permanent Fastening Makes More Sense
Sometimes permanent fastening makes more sense in certain applications where maintenance does not allow for constant resecuring of connections. For example, on bridges or an aircraft fuselage where access to inspect fasteners in person might be complicated if not impossible. Where reliability and permanent resistances to vibration are required, industrial fastenings like Structural Rivets can be a sensible permanent addition to construction processes.
The trade-off is clear, you cannot easily take them apart again but in industrial and structural application settings, that’s not a concern. The goal is to assemble and never look back with conviction that regardless of the conditions, it will stay solid.
Share the Load? Its More Complicated Than That!
Joints with multiple fasteners also run the risk of never sharing loads appropriately. The first fastener secured carries the load despite its intention maybe when all other bolts are finally tightened some load redistributes but it never does the job completely.
Under vibration, those fasteners with more load are more likely to loosen while simultaneously increasing load on the rest it’s bad news and can cause failure.
The proper sequence helps as does torque control starting from the middle going out in cross patterns keeps everything centered.
Maintenance Doesn’t Happen in Real Life But It Happens in Design
Designers assume all this proper installation and inspection will happen but people work in impossible situations getting what they can do get it done. Installation doesn’t always happen in proper positions making access more time consuming than efficiency; torque values are theoretical instead of empirical measurements taking physical feedback into consideration; schedules for inspection are fun ideas until projects get busy on other assignments.
This is why overtightening fastening makes sense instead if a joint can stay tight throughout design loads with little maintenance then it should hold-up realistically where inappropriate installation occurs and maintenance is less frequent with tolerable levels built-in through threads or joint design or going permanent keeps trouble at bay down the road.
Solutions That Connect With Connections Once and For All
There’s no easy solution to keeping fasteners tight better but understanding how external forces play out means solutions providing interfaces to those specific calls help solve those issues best.
